WebCT
Michele
Michele's Winter 2004/2005 Discussion Topics
JG
contribute
   
Discussion#1
Message no. 4
Discussion #1 Why Integrate the Interne
Why integrate the Internet into our lesson plans? What can the Internet do for lessons that you wouldn’t otherwise be able to do?
You must visit and discuss this topic at least 3 times in this time period and respond to the postings of your peers (move the conversation along, discuss, bring up new ideas and/or questions, etc.).
#13
   

Discussion#2
Message no. 5

Discussion #2 Evaluating Websites for Instructional Use
What reliability/credibility information should we consider when evaluating websites for instructional use? What about design issues? What other issues would be important to consider when determining whether we should include a website for instructional use?

You must visit and discuss this topic at least 3 times in this time period and respond to the postings of your peers (move the conversation along, discuss, bring up new ideas and/or questions, etc.).

   
Comment to add to discussion when it opens r17   Message no. 17 [Reply of: no. 12]
Author: Jerome Garfunkel (jerome.garfunkel)
Date: Monday, December 20, 2004 12:04am
Content is certainly one criteria to measure a web site. Other measurement criteria may include:
Navigation,
Presentation (style)
Multi-media (entertainment)
Readability
These and other criteria were identified in measuring the effectiveness of web design in a research paper, entitled Web-Based Learning: How Task Scaffolding and Web Site Design Support Knowledge Acquisition, by S. Kim MacGregor and Yiping Lou, in the ISTE Journal of Research on Technology in Education (JRTE) (Vol 37, no 2, p161).
     

Discussion#3 Message no. 6 JG replys waiting #14,15,16

Discussion #3 Instant Messenger (IM) in the Classroom
Educational technologies, researchers, theorists, teachers, etc. discusses various software applications for synchronous conferencing, including (but not limited to) Netmeeting (which allows many types of interactions) and other forms of Instant Messenger.

Respond to some of the following (please try to engender conversation about these topics...you may find that asking your own questions as well might help the discussion along).
1. Do you see any benefits and/or drawbacks to integrating these types of tools into your curricula? If so, what are they and why do you find them important?
2. How do you see these kinds of tools affecting the roles and/or workload of teachers in the future, if at all? And, how do you feel about that shift, if any?
3. Your students are likely using these types of tools every day, if they are in 5th grade or older (and possibly even younger). Do you think the role of these tools in the classroom will change because of the students' familiarity with the tools?
4. How do you think the students' heavy use of these tools might affect their writing, listening, and communication skills?

   

Discussion#4

(message#7)

Discussion #4 Communicative Aspects of the Internet
Visit 4 of the following websites to get a better idea about how to incorporate communicative aspects of the Internet into your curriculum. Discuss the merits of the activities you see. Between you, try to come up with a large list of annotated examples of how you could use these various TYPES of projects/ideas in your own classroom.

Keypals
• http://www.kidlink.org/KIDPROJ (projects that address epals or keypals)
• http://www.epals.com  (great site - added to jg resources)

Cooperative Research Projects
• http://www.interlink.org/nz/projects/chewfat/chewfat2.html
• http://www.learner.org/jnorth
• http://wilburnes.wcpss.net/tooth01.htm

Electronic Mentoring
• http://www.edc.org/CCT/telementoring/index2.html
• http://riceinfo.rice.edu/armadillo/Projects/letters.html
• http://riceinfo.rice.edu/armadillo/Projects

Ask an Expert
• http://www.askanexpert.com
• http://www.tapr.org/emissary
• http://walrus.wr.usgs.gov/docs/ask-a-ge.html

   
         

Assignment:

Contextual Background

Assignment InformationMaximum grade:  5
Due date:  November 28, 2004 (Late)

Instructions:  Contextual Background for Using Internet in the Classroom

Read the following:
Internet Access in Public Schools and Classrooms: 1994-2002
Read pages 10-23 (and all rest you are interested in) to get a research-based
contexts for how popular the Internet is in the Classroom.

Read at least one of the following:
Kennedy, Kristen. (2003). Writing with web logs. Technology and Learning.
Meyer, Katrina A. (2003). The web's impact on student learning. THE Journal.
• Salpeter, Judy. (2003). Web literacy and critical thinking: A teacher's tool kit. Technology and Learning.
Scott, Jaclyn. (2003). Don't forget the little people: A vision for an online kindergarten learning community. THE Journal.

Be sure to read the entire article, if there is a Next button at the end of the article (articles from THE Journal can be printed in full or emailed to your account)! Submit a reaction to each (in one submisstion - but no more than 150-250 words each) to this forum. Title this “Contextual Background.” Be sure to give me links to the sites where you are posting your documents.

Assignment files:
None

Submissions:
You can only submit your assignment once. No re-submission is permitted.

Notification:
The instructor will not be notified via email when you submit this assignment.

Assignment submission    
         

Assignment: Acceptable Use Policies

 

 

 

Acceptable Use Policies
Instructions
:
Your principal has recently discovered that you are completing a program in educational technology, and has decided that you would be a perfect choice for becoming the school’s Internet Safety expert. The principal has asked that you complete several specific projects:
Review current information about what types of information should be on a school’s Acceptable Use Policy by searching Internet resources and reputable educational technology journals (she wants at least five resources and two from reputable journals). Then, evaluate your school’s Acceptable Use Policy. The principal wants you to provide a summary of the strengths and weaknesses of the Acceptable Use Policy. Additionally, she wants you to make specific recommendations about what should be included in the “new” Acceptable Use Policy.
The information should be provided to the principal in a formal report. Your audience is the principal, so you should write the report as if you were providing it to her with the understanding that it would also go to other administration, school board members, and perhaps some parents. This document will represent you, so it should be written as such.
Submit this response using this forum.
Assignment files: None

Submissions:
You can only submit your assignment once. No re-submission is permitted.

Notification:
The instructor will not be notified via email when you submit this assignment.

Acceptable Use Policies
JG work-in-progress
Acceptable Use Policy pape

   
       

Assignment: 3

Internet Lesson Consumer

Assignment: Internet Lesson Consumer
Instructions: Locate at least five lesson plans on the web that integrate Internet into the curriculum (preferably your curriculum). Try to use at least three different lesson plan resources to locate this information. After you’ve located and read the five, choose two to evaluate. In your report to me, include:

1. The specific resources you used to search for the information
2. The URLs for the five lesson plans
Using the following questions, evaluate 2 of the lessons:1. Would you use this lesson? Why or why not?
2. What are the strengths of the lesson?
3. What are the weaknesses of the lesson?
4. What would you change in the lesson?
5. Did the plan address the multiple intelligences of the learners? If so, how? If not, what could be added or changed?
6. Was enough information provided so that you could teach this lesson? If not, what additional information would you need?
Some resources might include (you can use ANY others that you like):
* The Blue Web’n Library
* High Plains Regional Technology Consortium
* The Apple Learning Exchange
* The ThinkQuest Internet Challenge
* The WebQuest Page
* Virtual Field Trips Site
* Discovery.com
* Microsoft Lesson Connection
* The New York Times
* Smithsonian Institute
* United Nations
* U.S. DOE
Submit your assignment to this forum. It should be titled YourFirstInitialYourLastName_EvaluatingLessonPlans (e.g., MDornisch_EvaluatingLessonPlans)

 

Assignment: Internet Lesson Consumer
   
         
Assignments 4 Assignment: ISTE Articles
Instructions: Review at least 5 journal articles from Learning and Leading with Technology. Each article MUST describe the integration of the INTERNET into the classroom (preferably in your content area). Your "reviews" will consist of (1) a summary paragraph for each article, (2) a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of this particular use of Internet in the classroom, and (3) a statement about whether you would incorporate this lesson into your own classroom setting, if you had the opportunity. Please limit each review to three paragraphs, but provide enough information in the summary paragraph that someone who has not read the article can understand the specific use of the Internet. Please use APA style to reference the reviews.
Assignment: ISTE
A rticles

   
Assignments 5 Assignment: Evaluating Websites
Instructions: Choose a website that you have used in the classroom previously. Using the discussion forum on evaluating websites as the model for your evaluation, evaluate each site for its instructional quality, credibility, and site design. Try to keep your response between 800-1200 words
Assignment: Evaluating Websites
   
Assignments 6

Assignment: Nonlinear Reading Environments
Instructions: There is much debate the the "research" literature about the positive value of the nonlinear hyperlink capabilities that the web provides. When using the web in your classroom, do you think hyperlinks will add to or detract from your instruction (and the students' learning)? Use at least five resources from the C. W. Post library databases to

Earl Hood, student at UC Irvine, references hypertextnavigation.com
email address is amptone.com

Great resource of resources
http://www.hypertextnavigation.com/htgoals.htm

Assignment: Nonlinear Reading Environments
Assignment Information
Maximum grade: 25
Due date: January 28, 2005
   
Assignments 7 Assignment: Communicative Aspects of the Web
Instructions: Parents and school board members have been increasingly concerned about the safety of their children while engaging with online communication tools (email, chatrooms, Instant Messenger, discussion forums, etc.) because of the coverage in the news about online “predators.” They DO NOT want their children using these tools in school. However, the principal feels that such tools could help provide very meaningful learning environments. Come up with an argument for these tools (using reputable journals to strengthen your argument) AND create a list of rules for both teachers and students when using such tools in order to address the concerns of the board and the parents. Use at least two research-based journal articles and any other resources you can find as well as the course discussion forum on this topic (which will end Jan. 31st) to create your argument. Cite the sources from which you’ve gathered information. Try to keep your response to 1200-1500 words
Assignment: Communicative Aspects of the Web
Assignment Information
Maximum grade: 15
Due date: February 4, 2005
   
   

Very practical assignment.
Benefits outway liabilities:
Beneftits:i
> Multi-curtural, prejudice reduction, exotic experiences with places, with people (telementoring)
Liabilities:

Reading Videoconfeencing for K-12 Classrooms, Camille Cole, Kecia Ray, Jan Zanetis, ISTE publication: AProgram Development Guide, Copyright 2004. Very Practical Book, from page 1.
Are there substantial differences in a) hardware b) application c) conclusions, between video conferencing in K-12 classroom vs telementoring between Irv and the Montana college classroom.

Technical issues raised for video conferencing related to the CODEC.  Must each side of the conference agree to common CODEC and /or use common O/S and/or O/S Version and/or O/S Version Build, etc.

For Irv/Montana project, should we (do we) have a document camera. 
Can Irv get to know a little about the students in advance (JG will help prepare getting "familiar.")

   
Assignments 8-10:
Internet-based Lesson Plans
Instructions: Design 3 lessons that use Internet resources. Use 3 different models below to create these lessons.

* Electronic penpals or "keypals"
* Individual or cooperative group research projets
* Electronic mentoring (telementoring)
* One to one guidance
* Discussion forums
* Peer lounges

* Electronic (or virtual) field trips
* Group development of products
* Collaborative problem solving
* Parallel problem solving
* Real-time data analysis
* Social action projects

Be sure that your lessons are age approriate. Use the lesson plan format provided.

Assignments 8-10: Internet-based Lesson Plans
  Availability: December 20, 2004 11:00am - Unlimited
  Grade: -- / 30
   
Lesson Plan Assignment Working Draft

Web Quest Pop Quiz:

Name that Fact in the fastest time, in the least amount of steps.
How quickly, and how few steps can students answer the following questions:
Find anyone who was alive in Benjamin Franklin's life time, before 1790, and was still alive in 1868 when Molly Garfunkel was born.
Find weekly budget/shopping list for family living in Colonial Philadelphia (1750 - 1800)

The subjects of the webquests can of course be from the course subject context:
Identify modern decendents of John Adams,

Identify remnants of Civil War black/white separations

1) Lesson Plan PBL:  Create a 1905 Top Ten Music List
(Requires researching who and what was popular at turn of century)

2) Classroom-to-classroom portal between two high school - international project - 2 hour weekly interactive sessions, with pre and post preparation work at each end of the portal.

 

 


 

   
Michele course outline email So welcome to all of the students in the EDT 812 class. As you know by now,
this class has started. I wanted to discuss several things with you, and I
thought email would be a good forum for that.

There are 10 assignments each worth a different number of points.

Additionally, there are 7 discussion forums. The "main" discussion forum is
there for you to post questions about the course to each other or to me.
Hopefully, as a group, you will get used to going in and trying to clarify
anything you don't understand. However, it is my intention to check that
discussion forum daily just so that I can answer questions for you.

There is one "semester long" discussion forum, "Tracking a Listserv." You
will need to subscribe to the listserv of your choice. Typically this is
done by writing in the text of the message to the listserv "Subscribe
Michele Dornisch" (although you'd put your own name, not mine. You should
all be tracking a listserv immediately (joining and then reviewing and
responding). Each week during the course, you should provide one or two
summaries of what is going on in that listserv. I would prefer for you to
track an educational technology listserv, and as a result, I have decided to
provide a list for you to choose from. Note, though, that I've also
provided several places where you can find listservs (preferably regarding
educational technology) on your own, if you don't have much interest in
these.

Therefore, here goes:

* EDTECH Topics in Educational Technology listserv@msu.edu

*subscribed INCLASS Internet in the Classroom
listproc@schoolnet.carleton.edu

* * * * * * * * * **********
INCLASS:
**********
INCLASS (bilingual French and English) is part of Canada's SchoolNet's on-going contribution to education research of vital interest and importance to the international education community. It is a discussion list about using INTERNET in the classroom.
INCLASS enjoys its partnerships with the education, science, and business communities. We enjoy operating on the cutting edge, in the spirit of research and the pursuit of new knowledge. We encourage you to originate and participate in INCLASS research projects. It's always exciting!
To Subscribe:
E-mail message, leaving the Subject line blank to: listproc@schoolnet.carleton.ca
Body of message: SUBSCRIBE INCLASS Irvin Beard (your name)
TO UNSUBSCRIBE:
Send your message, leaving the Subject line blank, to:
LISTPROC@SCHOOLNET.CARLETON.CA
Body of message: UNSUBSCRIBE INCLASS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

* ITS Integrating Technology in Schools
listserve@unm.edu

*subscribed SIGTEL-L Telecommunications in Education
listserv@unmvma.unm.edu

* WWWEDU Educational Web Discussion
listproc@kudzu.cnidr.org

Each of the remaining 5 discussion forums have a specific date attached
(I've changed that to make it obvious). Please don't reply to the
discussions unless they are open. Sorry for not making that clear.

I also wanted to touch base with you all about how to post to discussion
forums. It seems clear to me that by just saying "I agree with you" or
something of that nature, you really aren't posting something meaningful.
Please think carefully about the issues, as they are important issues as we
move into the information age. You need to explain what you mean and
support your ideas. Just posting, for example, that "site design" is
important when examining whether to use a website in the classroom is not
enough. What is important about site design and why is it important for
LEARNING from the site? That is the kind of information you want to get at
when posting to the discussion forums.

Please also note that you should be constantly returning to these discussion
forums (the ones that are active) during the discussion sessions. For each
discussion forum that is NOT the listserv discussion, you should post at
least three responses, but they should be thoughtful responses.

If you have any questions regarding the WebCT environment, you can look the
answers up here e-learning guide http://e-learning.liu.edu/student.htm.
Or, you can just email me.

Finally, all assignments should be posted within WebCT, so that I can find
them there. Once the due date is passed for each, I will grade that
assignment and post the pointes you've received. Do understand, though,
that simply by completing an assignment, you do not receive full points.
You should take care to put effort, thought, critical thinking, and
reflection into your projects.

Email me If you have any questions, but please do get started with the
course.

===========================================
Michele M. Dornisch, PhD
Assistant Professor, Educational Technology
15 B. Davis Schwartz Library
Long Island University, C. W. Post Campus
720 Northern Boulevard
Brookville, NY 11548
516-299-4115
516 299-4167 (fax)
mdorn@liu.edu

     
discussion entry


Why do you think students should be using the Internet, rather than the library? What
does it afford us? What can we do with the Internet that we wouldn't otherwise be able
to do? For example, it seems clear to me that we can do research using the Internet.
So what? We can do research in the library. What about the credibility of the
information on the Internet? Is it as credible as information in the library? What about
the information on the Internet makes it so useful?

What about the Internet in general, as a tool, not just to "acquire" information, makes it
so useful???

The computer is like a "swiss army" educational tool.  It is more of a facilitator of problem solving than it is the solution to any specific problem.  The internet, (broadband in particular) is one of the handy tools built into our "swiss army" educational tool.  It is arguably the most useful and versatile of all of the tools packed into our digital arsenal. There are a number of reasons I believe, why the internet plays (or can/should play) such an important role in the classroom.  In no particular order, first there is the immediacy of information.  The timliness of the information is often up-to-the-minute (up-to-the-second?) and the response time, from inquirery to desired-knowledge is measured in seconds, not minutes, hours or days. Second is the vast array of resource material that is accessable from the internet.  I don't know of a library that boasts of such a robust on-shelf inventory of materials as is available digitally on the internet.  Third is the delivery system.  Often the searching for information is but a step to solving a bigger problem.  There are times when information is provided and can be fleeting - we can throw it away after using it.  There are other times when we may want to "keep a copy handy" for later referencing.  The internet accomadates both. The discarding of information after it has been used, is possible only because of the ease to access the information in the first place.  When one knows that one will likely to return to an online reference for later evaluation, one often downloads a copy of that material to one's local computer.  But with the ease of knowledge access, retrieving information from one's local computer often is no easier (and at times more difficult) than retrieving information from the internet.  This same achitectural design of accessing information, is employed in some computer hardware "client-server" systems.  "Thin" clients and "fat" clients are variations of a system configuration where computer processing is done more locally (fat client) or more remotely from the server (thin client).

Even if one knows that a chart or some other information will be required for later reference,

n general, and the internet specifally

     
 
The Center for Technology and School Change's vision is built on the assumption that change evolves through steps and stages, Our "situated learning" approach provides personalized professional development and moves teachers from awareness to technology integration through hands-on activities. We use a project-based approach to address the standards and adapt technology to enhance student learning experiences.

Initially, trainers work with small groups of educators to discuss current projects. A butterfly unit, for instance, may start with word processing as students compose poetry. Over time teachers might learn to create a database to classify and sort. A next step might be learning to help students utilize the web to follow the migration of the monarch.

Facilitators provide support by working with teachers to implement projects and assist with classroom management techniques. This cooperative process thoughtfully infuses technology into the classroom.

"Evaluation is part of a reflective process. The more reflective we are, the more likely we are to improve our practice."
-Charol Shakeshaft, 1999

Yes but:  Students difficulty (anyone's) with evaluating others' work is the psychological issue as well as a skills issue.   Evaluation implies judgementalism often, or is too easily mistaken as the same.  For evaluation to be pure reflection and thereby an exercize in "pure" critical thinking, it must be stripped of any hint of judgementalism.  It hinders both the crtic and the critiquee.  Anonymity is one possibility.  But reflection (or any writing meant to be seen by other eyes) without dialog wastes much of the value of reflection as a critical thinking exercize.  The dialog is critical. 

Great Resource - Columbia Univ Center for Tech & School Change

http://www.tc.columbia.edu/ctsc/CTSCfinal/

     

© 2004, Jerry Garfunkel ..... 172 Tinker Street ..... Woodstock, NY .... 12498 .... Tel/Fax +1 845 679 0121 ..... www.jeromegarfunkel.com ..... jerry@jeromegarfunkel.com